Blocking ads removes funding from us!
Researching and writing articles takes a lot of time. Running our infrastructure costs money. All of this is financed through advertising revenue. We don't like advertising either – that's why we avoid annoying banners and pop-ups. Please give us a chance and disable your ad blocker! Alternatively, you can support us here voluntarily.

Google Fonts Data Breach: What to do? All information at a glance

Featured image: © 2022 Google

The best Amazon dealsDaily selected tech deals
David Wurm
About the author

David Wurm

Do that TechnikNews-Ding together with a great team since 2015. Works in the background on the server infrastructure and is also responsible for everything editorial. Is fascinated by current technology and enjoys blogging about everything digital. In his free time he can often be found developing webs, taking photographs or making radio.

David has already written 993 articles and left 385 comments.

notification settings
notifications about
guest
Your name, which will be shown publicly.
We will not publish your email address.

170 Comments
latest
oldest Best
Dominik Lenne

I have now replaced the YouTube video in the iframe with an image with a data protection notice.
When you click, the actual video is only loaded.

Dominik Lenne

Hello, as you write correctly, embedded youtube videos also pull google fonts from the google server. Many websites have embedded YouTube videos. Are there already warnings about this? What should I do? Always replace embed with image link? Show the consent page *before* the actual page even loads (since the request is made on load, not when watching the video)?
Thanks for tips!

Klemm

What about CDNs for images (such as: Imgix)? Does anyone have any info/experience? Thanks & LG!

Jojo

Hello, everyone! Thanks a lot for this! I have an alternative Google Fonts Checker: https://devotion-it.de/online-marketing/google-fonts-checker/
This also shows the fonts used.
Best regards, Jojo

Hobby IT snooper

Everything – really EVERYTHING is there (in the log files)

> Eva's IP address (212.95.5.190) 15 hits in 3 seconds
> Access of the netEstate crawler (81.209.177.xxx)
> Access to the scrapy crawler (176.9.20.xxx)

w14201c

The basis of the argument of the esteemed colleague is the judgment of the ECJ on October 19.10.2016, 582, C-14/49, as he writes himself. Only it is not quoted completely and correctly: In the original text, the judgment clearly restricts the conditions under which the IP address is personal data. See paragraph XNUMX, which is also quoted in the warning. There is a clear "... if he has legal means ...". You have this as a site operator or as “Fa. Google” certainly not. The reference judgment is therefore about a completely different situation and thus the factual and legal basis for the argumentation in the warnings is omitted. The link to the original text: https://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?docid=184668&doclang=DE

Photography

My website http://www.thomassalvato.at was also affected. The website was made with WIX. Lt. A local integration of the fonts is not possible with WIX. However, I have a corresponding entry regarding Google Fonts in my data regulations.
Eva Z.'s IP address was not in the log files. This was checked by the IT of the website operator.

Lawyer

Interesting: According to his website, the lawyer completed his law degree in 16 semesters, with a minimum duration of 8 semesters. He "used up" 4 law firms for his legal training, which is unusual. I draw my own conclusions from this and threw his letter in the dustbin. In the meantime, it seems largely certain that his actions were illegal. Such an amateurish action is not worth paying attention to.

Rudiger Schultz

Google Fonts in other Google products (MAPS)

In such cases, it is not enough to simply deactivate all “own” calls to GoogleFonts (fonts.gstatic.com or fonts.googleapis.com). You also have to add something to your own GoogleMaps Javascript application.
Here is the link (helped me a lot for our projects):

https://cameronjonesweb.com.au/blog/fix-google-maps-including-overriding-roboto-fonts/#comment-15925

Grigory

How can I prevent Google Maps from downloading the fonts.gstatic.com or fonts.googleapis.com fonts?

With kind regards,

Georg

A customer received TWO letters, each from client Eva, each for the same website, once from 12.08. AND once from 17.08. BUT each with a different IP.

I have no idea why the lady goes to one side twice, resulting in discomfort. So maybe it wasn't a real person who called up the pages. Where can I report this, that's wonderful proof, or am I seeing it wrong?

Banana Joe

This is not proof, but an indication.

Michael S

I am not affected myself, but have been following this warning for a few days
Various websites advise people to comply with the information. However, the letter does not contain any authorization. This can only be accessed via a link. And this is where the following problems arise:

  1. The content of this page can be changed at any time.
  2. According to statements by those affected, there is an error during the signature verification (yellow exclamation mark)

So before I give someone information, I have to be 100% sure that the rightful person is also requesting this information.

So I'm going into the next GDPR trap, if you simply give the applicant information.
Or am I misunderstanding something in this context?

Banana Joe

I have pointed out to Mr. RA for a customer that the IP without a time stamp of access does not allow me to make a clear assignment to his client. He should please let me know when his client accessed my customer's website.

Peter Solc

PS-TRAINING GmbH received a warning today. Supposedly, Mrs. Eva Z. was on the web address stress.at (a domain that is redirected to the main page solc.at)
I will have the logs checked, report this to the wko and will probably file a complaint with the RAKNOE after legal advice.
Peter Solc (Managing Director)

Ann

I can't find the IP address or other addresses in my log files, but only up to 7.8. Everything else has already been deleted, since I read that many attacks took place from August 5.8th, it is of course possible that it happened before that, but the missing date makes things more difficult on purpose. I will write negative information and that's it, because myself if the lady was on my website, her data is already deleted anyway..

Johanna

Dear affected parties, I would like to provide you with the statement from the legal department of the Medical Association of Upper Austria – please do not refer to it directly if you use it, thank you. Best wishes and good luck to you all, Johanna, referring to the legal letter from RA Mag. Marcus Hohenecker in the legal case “Google Fonts data protection violation” we are allowed to comment as follows: The letter alleges a data protection violation – caused by the use of a Google service – and the existence of a claim for damages totaling € 190,00 (including costs).   The actual existence of a violation of data protection regulations depends on the technical background of your respective homepage: If the IP addresses are actually transmitted to Google, this would be a violation of the provisions of the GDPR, unless the consent of the homepage users was obtained beforehand! Please clarify this with the creator of your homepage.   Even if the alleged data protection violation did occur on your homepage, it is currently disputed whether there is any right to claim damages in such a case. In Germany, there is a lower court decision on this matter which affirms a claim for damages; in Austria, there are currently no court decisions on this matter. There is currently a case pending before the ECJ to clarify the requirements for such a claim for damages; however, a decision by the ECJ will probably not be available for several months.   The decision as to whether you comply with the payment request and accept the settlement or simply comply with the request for information (see further down in this text) and submit a cease-and-desist declaration (declaration that your homepage has been redesigned and that in future no personal data will be transmitted to Google without the consent of the person concerned) is at your personal discretion. We consider the risk of an actual legal action and/or a complaint being filed with the data protection authority to be low.   It is strongly recommended that you redesign your homepage or have your homepage creator redesign it in such a way that no more data transfers occur or can occur without your consent. In general, we advise against using Google products on homepages, as these often involve data transfers.   It is also crucial that – if you decide not to pay on time – you comply with the request for information in accordance with Art. 15 GDPR within one month at the latest (after receipt of the letter of request) and submit a cease and desist declaration. Make sure that all points of the request for information attached to the lawyer's letter are addressed. A copy of the processed data must also be transmitted. If you do not have any data or if the person is unknown to you, you must provide a blank statement (notification that no personal data of the person concerned will be processed). Please send the answer to the request for information and the cease and desist declaration by post to Mag. Hohenecker.   If your homepage was created by a third-party company, you may be entitled to recourse claims against them, which you may have to pursue in court.   If you have legal protection insurance, we recommend that you contact them.   Summary of the steps to take if you decide against timely payment: • Contact the website designer (to determine whether data is actually being transmitted) •... Continue reading ...

heeheeee

…. it is noticeable that customers whose domains are on the same host all received the letter and customers whose domains are on a different host have so far been spared...... so the surfing behavior of the dear lady is very noticeable in this respect, since between the websites yes there is no connection, except that they are just on the same host…. in order to establish a connection you have to search specifically for it... or just use a service that indexes the domains by host....

Roman Chlada

Important for users of WIX.com and similar platforms:

The Munich judgment is justified by the fact that it would be possible to integrate Google Fonts locally without any difficulties. This is probably correct if you work directly with the html code. It also doesn't seem to be difficult with Joomla or WordPress.

However, it is not possible if the website was created using a platform such as WIX.com. In this case, the html code remains the property of the platform and you are completely dependent on the automated functions and options of the platform.

Of course, local integration of Google Fonts does not occur because nobody outside of the German-speaking world is bothered by it.

On such platforms, there should be no other way to avoid using Google Fonts than to find out for yourself which of the available fonts are Google Fonts and which are not (they are of course not marked as such in any way). If you find one that is not a Google Font, you can change the fonts accordingly, which also changes the appearance of the website.

There is no guarantee that the platform will not switch entirely to Google Fonts at a later date and replace the other fonts with equivalents.

The Munich judgment is not applicable in this case because the damage, which is not damage, cannot be remedied in one go.

Looser

The lawyer in question was a top candidate for the Pirate Party and appeared several times on Oe24.TV as a vehement opponent of compulsory vaccination. Maybe he needs money again for founding a new party and for the election campaign since the Pirate Party has disappeared into oblivion.

Alois

Unfortunately, I am not an IT expert and I have a technical question:
In my letter, only the screenshot of the source code is visible. Now if someone just looks at the source code (e.g. view-source:https://....), without having previously visited the page normally, are the Google fonts loaded at all?

PS: Thank you very much for reporting on this page!

Martin

Not really, because view-source only loads text content into the browser.

Johann

I too received the lawyer's letter last week and stupidly opened it.
The address was not my name but the title of my website and an incomplete address. Unfortunately, the postman knows me well, otherwise I wouldn't have gotten the letter.
I immediately contacted the WKO's legal service and they advised me to react to the letter (deadline extension).
However, after reading the posts here, I'm unsure if it was wise to respond to the letter.
I had actually integrated Google Fonts (via a WP template, YouTube embedding, Google Captcha).

StenM2020

Article in the Krone – you should also leave appropriate comments here: https://www.krone.at/2790403

Eugen

I also wrote to 6 customers this week from the warning lawyer. And there are more every day….

Heike

New letters continue to be sent?!

Werner

I also got the letter today, but it is about a website that is not mine at all. A brazen attempt at rip-off. Apart from that, the lawyer tells me the IP address of his client in the letter - is that compliant with data protection, since it is not about my website, she (allegedly) visited it?

sunny

I run a web agency myself and some of my clients are already affected. Today I will file a complaint with the public prosecutor's office against the client named in the letter.

Myst111

On what grounds or what criminal offense?

Helmut

Suspicion of fraud in the proceedings; if an automated search was used (which is highly likely given the evidence).

Maria Sailer

Can you join the lawsuit?

Myst111

According to the motto "The spirits I called" I will ask the sites Hohenecker.at and Datenschutzanwalt.eu which of my data will be processed. Perhaps others here are also interested in knowing what Mag. Hohenecker stores about us and thus also learns how much effort such a data collection causes, especially if it sometimes demands 100 or 1.000 from him ;-).

Georg

Perhaps this has already been mentioned here, so please forgive me if I repeat it: I just read it in its data protection declaration on hochecker.at:1.4. Access (such as the IP address) is also not logged. The IP address is only processed by the respective web server for the provision of the website, without us having access to this information.

Christian

I think I checked that he's at world4you. In any case, it is stored for 2 weeks and every website operator has access to it.

https://www.world4you.com/faq/de/dsgvo/faq.wie-lange-werden-webserver-logfiles-gespeichert.html

Johanna

unfortunately I also got this letter, then I did the self-test of the WKO for my site and the google fonts don't seem to be integrated locally. I'm overwhelmed by various troubleshooting videos and suggestions, I'm not really trained in wordpress. give up now, will contact the WKO in the morning.
after my provider is also world4you, it seems that I can't check if Eva was on my side.
I don't think it's right that two people cause so much trouble.

Yomi

Which self test? Don't know anything about the WKO. Please link!

Matthew A

install the plugin mentioned in the article above. works uncomplicated and without much setup.

otherwise post your email address. I or someone else here would be happy to help.

Greetings from the night shift

Ann

I'm also with world4you - unfortunately they won't help you any further! I don't know which dates either provider saves, they just replied to me that it will be deleted after 14 days, so I probably wouldn't be able to find the IP address anymore..

Max

world4you has already reacted and published this

https://www.world4you.com/faq/de/top-themen/faq.abmahnung-wegen-google-fonts-wo-finde-ich-die-logfiles.html

there is also (at least on a wordpress site) the possibility to look at the stats, log in to the admin site and then click https://meine.url/stats Yourself

Claudia

https://de.wordpress.org/plugins/disable-remove-google-fonts/ - Hi Johanna - I'm also totally tech-silly - but I managed to do it in WordPress - maybe you can too.

Stay cool

The letter was delivered without proof. Without a registered letter, you may not have received the letter at all. If a registered letter comes, just don't accept it. Then this lawyer will stop with this nonsense.

Ann

Does anyone have experience of how to find out which data is stored on which person and for what purpose? Unfortunately, my hoster world4you does not help me here..

quarter

At world4you you get access to the log files via FTP. everything is very simply and clearly documented in the my.world4you portal

Searching the logs didn't show the IP address I gave, so the "lady" wasn't even on my website

Pete

The question is whether she was on the website between the 4.8 (=date of the power of attorney) and the date of the attorney's letter. Unfortunately, maybe intentionally, there is no date in the letter when she was on the website. I can't find any IP in the log files either, but I can only check this retrospectively up to 7.8.

Ann

ok thanks for the answer.. world4you deletes the data every 14 days, so I think the IP address would no longer be available either..

mankra

Apparently, the only warning currently being given is because of Google Fonts.
Is the integration of scripts, images, libraries via CDN outside the EU also illegal according to the GDPR?

Max

That depends on what they send along... I don't think you can give a general answer to that.

Stefan

I agree with that. If it's just about the IP address, then pictures and JavaScripts leave that anyway.
That means things like bootstrap or material design or jQuery would probably also be something for this scam.